What couple is suing Love It or List It?

A North Carolina couple, Deena Murphy and Timothy Sullivan, sued the producers of HGTV's Love It or List It (Big Coat TV) and their contractor (Aaron Fitz Construction) in 2016, alleging "disastrous" and "irreparably damaged" renovations, shoddy work, and claims that the show's business model was unfair and the work was staged, though the case was settled later. Another lawsuit was filed in 2019 by a Vancouver couple, Almeida and Waine, against the show's Vancouver production team, alleging a contractor hired was inexperienced and the work faulty, according to CBC News.

What are the lawsuits against Joanna Gaines?

Joanna Gaines, along with her husband Chip, has faced several lawsuits, including a recent breach-of-contract suit from their former literary agent over a book deal (filed Dec 2022), a property dispute settled in 2017, and a settled EPA case regarding lead paint in 2018. More recently, they settled a dispute over back taxes for their historic castle in 2024.
 

Did Love It or List It get sued for damages?

Yes, Love It or List It faced a significant lawsuit from a North Carolina couple, Deena Murphy and Timothy Sullivan, who claimed shoddy work, irreparable damage (like ruined floors, holes), and misuse of funds by the production company (Big Coat TV) and contractor (Aaron Fitz Construction) in 2016; the case ended in a confidential settlement in 2017, but revealed behind-the-scenes issues and alleged scripting. 

Why is Hillary no longer on Love It or List It?

Hilary Farr left Love It or List It because after nearly two decades, she felt the show had become "stale," "formulaic," and "boring," prompting her to seek new creative challenges, a decision also influenced by her cancer battle changing her perspective on life and wanting to do more meaningful work and enjoy each day, according to People.com. 

Are David and Hilary friends in real life?

Yes, Hilary Farr and David Visentin from Love It or List It are genuinely good friends in real life, describing their relationship as like family or siblings, and they continue to stay in touch even after she left the show in 2023, with David saying they'll be "friends forever". Their on-screen chemistry and banter come from a deep, long-standing platonic bond, not romance, and they enjoy hanging out and talking about life outside of filming, according to Realtor.com and Swooon.
 

'Love It Or List It' Lawsuit

Is Hilary Farr still married?

Personal life. Farr married Canadian TV producer Gordon Farr in 1982. She gave birth to their son in 1983. The couple divorced in 2008.

How many families lost their homes from extreme makeovers?

As of 2020, nine of the original show's recipient families have given up their homes due to financial issues, which included two foreclosures.

Do the homeowners on Love It or List It get paid?

No, homeowners on Love It or List It don't get paid; they actually pay for the renovations themselves, often with a significant budget (historically $50k, now higher), plus the cost of any purchased furniture, with the show providing the design/build expertise but not funding the actual construction or furnishings, although they get the benefit of filming and potential staging. 

Who gets the 418 million settlement?

Who qualifies for settlement payments? Anyone who sold a home after Oct. 31, 2019, will be eligible for a payment, so long as it was listed in an MLS and a commission was paid. Sellers should receive notification if they're entitled to a payment.

What health problems does Joanna Gaines have?

Joanna Gaines has dealt with a chronic back injury from high school cheerleading, requiring two microdiscectomy surgeries (one in 2001, another in late 2022) to fix herniated discs, leading to hospital stays for recovery, but recent online rumors about severe illnesses like lupus are unconfirmed clickbait; she often writes about finding balance amidst her busy family life and work.
 

Is Clint Harp still friends with Chip and Joanna?

Chip and Joanna Gaines remain friends with Clint despite no longer working together. Success from Fixer Upper led Clint to close Harp Design Co., allowing him to focus on his new ventures and creative outlets.

What happened to Joanna Gaines' son?

Joanna and Chip Gaines' eldest son, Drake, is now a college junior, balancing life as a baseball player.

What is the lawsuit against Marrs and Craddock?

In 2021, Jenny and Dave were sued by Dana Craddock and Tyler Craddock for $75,000. The Craddocks claimed their home was renovated as part of "Fixer to Fabulous," but that Marrs Construction and Marrs Developing failed to obtain proper permits. That lawsuit was settled out of court as well in March 2022.

What happened to Eric the contractor on Love It or List It?

HGTV contractor Eric Eremita left Love It or List It after a severe battle with COVID-19 in 2020, which required hospitalization and time on a ventilator, leading him to focus on his own projects, including a potential new show called Homeboys and his clothing line, THIRTEENbyEricEremita, after recovering from the near-fatal illness.
 

Who is suing Joanna Gaines?

Literary agency Vigliano Associates filed suit in a New York court alleging breach of contract against authors Chip and Joanna Gaines, as well as their business enterprises and their current management, United Talent Agency.

How much does it cost to hire Chip and Joanna?

Chip & Joanna Gaines's speaking fee typically ranges from $300,000 to $400,000. The lower end usually applies to virtual engagements, while the higher end is for in-person events in the US. However, fees may exceed this range for a variety of reasons, like extended activities or international travel.

Why did Bob Silva leave this old house?

Original host Bob Vila left the show in 1989 following a dispute about doing commercials. According to news reporter Barbara Beck, Vila was fired by WGBH Boston over making TV commercials for Rickel Home Centers, Home Depot's competitor.

Why is Hillary not going to be on Love It or List It?

“I've given it so many years of my life,” Farr told People in 2023, adding, “It's been incredibly gratifying, but now it's time for me to move on.” Hilary Farr revealed that she made the decision almost a year before announcing she is leaving HGTV's Love It or List It, realizing she needed to explore new opportunities.

What disability does Ty Pennington have?

Television host Ty Pennington explains how ADHD and neurodivergence can be a strength — especially in skilled trade careers: “You may think it's a disability or a liability, but it can actually be your superpower.” His YouTube docuseries, "Skills Jam," follows teens competing in trades like carpentry, plumbing, ...

Do the families have to pay a mortgage on an extreme home makeover?

No, Extreme Makeover: Home Edition generally does not pay the families' existing mortgages or provide cash for them; they provide a renovated home, but families are still responsible for property taxes, insurance, utilities, and any existing mortgage debt, which has unfortunately led to some families facing foreclosure or financial strain because the new, larger homes come with higher costs, as explained in these articles from Substack, Realtor.com, and St. Augustine Record. While the show aimed to help, the long-term financial burden of the upgraded homes, higher property values, and increased expenses sometimes created new problems, despite the producers providing financial advice and sometimes covering initial costs. 

How much is it to hire Hilary Farr?

Hilary Farr's design fees for private clients aren't widely published, but she runs Hilary Farr Designs, offering textiles and home goods through her brand, while her Love It or List It work is salaried by HGTV, not directly by homeowners. Booking her for speaking engagements costs a significant amount, starting in the tens of thousands of dollars (e.g., $25k-$39,999+), suggesting high-end private projects would also command substantial fees, likely negotiated through her agency or firm for personalized services.
 

Are David and Hillary friends in real life?

Yes, Hilary Farr and David Visentin from Love It or List It are genuinely good friends in real life, describing their relationship as like family or siblings, and they continue to stay in touch even after she left the show in 2023, with David saying they'll be "friends forever". Their on-screen chemistry and banter come from a deep, long-standing platonic bond, not romance, and they enjoy hanging out and talking about life outside of filming, according to Realtor.com and Swooon.
 

Where does Hilary Farr live now?

Hilary Farr primarily lives in Raleigh, North Carolina, where she built a custom home after finding her initial bungalow beyond saving, but she also maintains a home in Toronto, Canada, where she raised her son and often spent time during the pandemic. She splits her time between these two locations, with Raleigh being a major hub for her personal projects and Love It or List It filming.