What happens if you break Amish rules?

Breaking Amish rules, especially after baptism, leads to social consequences like shunning (Meidung), where community members limit contact, avoid eating with or talking to the individual to encourage repentance, but this is usually temporary, with forgiveness possible if they confess; persistent defiance results in excommunication (Bann) and permanent shunning, cutting off contact entirely, though those who leave before baptism aren't punished.

What happens if you disobey the Amish?

If Amish church members break their vows of baptism by disobeying religious leaders or church regulations and refuse to confess their error, they will face excommunication. Based on several biblical scriptures, the church shuns ex-members to remind them of their disobedience in hopes of winning them back.

Can Amish use condoms?

While generally discouraged or forbidden by religious doctrine (Ordnung) in most Old Order Amish communities, as children are seen as blessings from God, some Amish individuals, especially in less traditional groups or facing health/financial hardships, may quietly use natural family planning or even modern contraception, though this isn't openly endorsed and can vary. Condoms, as a modern birth control method, fall under these general restrictions but exceptions occur, particularly in more liberal communities or where economic pressures mount. 

What punishment do some Amish groups inflict on those who break the rules?

An Amish person who has taken the church vow, and who has been found guilty by the bishop of breaking one of the Ordnung rules, can be punished by the Meidung (excommunication or shunning).

Can Amish go back after being shunned?

Any member is free to leave. A member who has left may even be allowed to return within a short time. A member who leaves permanently will, however, be shunned. Shunning means that the person will forever be considered an outsider -- a stranger -- and will not be allowed to participate in the community ever again.

I Was Amish. This Is What Happens When You Break the Rules

How many wifes can Amish have?

Amish men can only have one wife at a time, as polygamy (having multiple wives) is not practiced, and divorce is generally not allowed, making marriages monogamous lifelong commitments, though widowers can remarry within their community, often to an older single woman or a widow for companionship or family formation. 

Do Amish girls get pregnant during Rumspringa?

Rumspringa is a period that begins at age sixteen and ends with the promise of baptism, during this period young Amish are exposed to the outside world. Another problem the Amish community faces during the Rumspringa period is unexpected pregnancy.

What do Amish use instead of toilet paper?

Amish people traditionally use simple, reusable items like old rags or cloth, alongside readily available natural materials such as leaves, corn cobs, or even newspaper pages, often seeing manufactured toilet paper as an unnecessary luxury, though some progressive groups do use it. Their choices reflect resourcefulness, simplicity, and waste reduction, with reusable cloths being washed and reused for hygiene.
 

Why do Amish remove their teeth?

Amish people sometimes have teeth removed, often by unlicensed local "dentists," to avoid the high costs of modern dental care, view dentures as a simpler, cheaper solution, or as a cultural practice (like a rite of passage or pre-marriage), but this is often due to poverty, isolation from mainstream healthcare, and traditional practices, leading to poor oral health and reliance on extractions rather than fillings or crowns. 

Do the Amish have SSN?

No, most Amish people do not have Social Security Numbers (SSNs) because their religious beliefs exempt them from participating in the system, opting out of benefits and taxes, though they do pay other taxes like income and property taxes and rely on community care instead of government aid, with exemptions secured via IRS Form 4029. While they avoid SSNs for religious reasons, they do have government IDs for other purposes, and the IRS may assign an SSN if needed for specific tax filings, but the goal is to remain outside the system. 

Do Amish ladies wear bras?

Yes, most Amish women wear bras, but they are typically plain, functional cotton styles (not lacy or fancy), and in some very conservative communities, a hand-sewn alternative garment might be used instead of a store-bought bra for modesty and nursing needs. The specific undergarments vary by community, but the general principle is simplicity and practicality, not adornment. 

Do Amish females shave?

No, generally Amish women do not shave; they typically do not remove body hair, including leg or underarm hair, as it's seen as vanity or going against their simple lifestyle, with some communities even forbidding it, contrasting with Amish men who often shave their faces clean but grow beards. 

What do Amish brides do on wedding night?

On their wedding night, an Amish woman spends her first night as a wife in her parents' home, often with playful pranks from friends, before helping with cleanup the next day, as the "honeymoon" involves visiting relatives to receive gifts, not a separate trip. The evening involves celebration, but the focus is on community and preparation for starting their new life, often living with parents initially. 

At what age do Amish girls marry?

Amish girls typically get married in their early 20s, often between ages 20 and 22, usually shortly after being baptized into the church during their late teens or early twenties, with dating starting around 16 and partners found at social events like Sunday singings. 

What is the average income of an Amish family?

Amish family income varies significantly by community, with older estimates suggesting averages around $40,000-$60,000, while modern estimates place it higher, with some non-farming households reaching $87,000+; however, many families are self-sufficient, prosperous, and report incomes below the poverty line but are not impoverished, relying on strong community support, skilled trades (carpentry, construction, furniture), organic farming, and diverse local businesses, with some families achieving significant wealth. 

How do Amish deal with periods?

Amish women manage periods using traditional, reusable methods like cloth pads (often homemade rags) for absorption, similar to historical practices before modern disposables, focusing on resourcefulness and cleanliness by washing and reusing them, while also relying on family planning through calendar-based fertility awareness to avoid pregnancy, reflecting their simple, faith-based lifestyle. 

Do the Amish circumcise their boys?

Yes, many Amish communities practice infant male circumcision, often arranged through midwives, though it's not universal across all groups, with about two-thirds of communities reportedly promoting it as a health practice rather than a strict religious ritual. 

Why do Amish sleep with a board between them?

Bundling, or tarrying, is the traditional practice of wrapping a couple together in a bed, sometimes with a board between the two of them, usually as a part of courting behavior.

What language do Amish people speak?

Amish people primarily speak Pennsylvania Dutch (Pennsylvania German) (their home language), English (for interacting with the outside world and in education), and High German (for religious services and scripture), using three languages to navigate their distinct cultural and religious life. Pennsylvania Dutch, their first language, is a German dialect that developed from immigrants in the 18th century, with some English influence, while High German connects them to their religious heritage.
 

Do Amish men wear underpants?

Yes, most Amish men wear underwear, typically simple, practical styles like boxers or briefs, similar to store-bought basic cotton ones, though some very traditional groups might have rules against them or prefer homemade versions, with a focus on modesty and plainness rather than modern, fancy designs. 

Do some cultures not wipe after pooping?

Not all countries or cultures use toilet paper to wipe their bums. This can be because of cultures that have traditionally used alternatives to toilet paper and therefore never really used it or lack of access to toilet paper.

How do Amish dispose of human waste?

The Amish method of waste management, mainly through composting toilets, is a crucial example of their sustainable practices. These toilets decompose human waste naturally, converting it into compost. This compost enriches agricultural soil, closing the nutrient loop and reducing the need for chemical fertilizers.

What is the oldest age a woman can get pregnant naturally?

There's no strict upper limit, but natural pregnancy becomes very rare after 45, with fertility dropping sharply due to fewer, lower-quality eggs, though documented cases of natural conception exist into the late 50s, like Barbara Higgins at 57, and even older with medical help, with the oldest natural case verified around 59 (Dawn Brooke). Most women need assistance (like IVF/donor eggs) after their mid-40s, as ovulation becomes infrequent and eggs have more chromosomal issues.
 

Is inbreeding common in Amish?

Yes, the Amish practice a form of inbreeding, or more accurately, endogamy (marrying within their closed community), which leads to higher rates of genetic relatedness and the increased prevalence of specific genetic conditions, as they descend from a small group of founders with limited gene flow from outsiders. While they avoid close cousin marriage (first cousins), their limited pool of marriage partners, due to cultural isolation, means many marriages are between second or third cousins, increasing the chance of recessive disorders appearing, like Ellis-van Creveld syndrome (dwarfism with extra fingers). 

How to tell if an Amish girl is married?

Amish married women wear white bonnets. 👒Women who are not yet married wear black bonnets. In these candid shots of Amish woodworkers in our woodshops, how many are married?