Who has better toilet paper Costco or Sam's Club?

Costco's Kirkland Signature toilet paper often offers better overall value with more sheets per roll and lower cost per sheet, making it more economical, while Sam's Club's Member's Mark is frequently described as softer and less linty, though some recent quality changes have been noted; preference often comes down to whether you prioritize value (Costco) or softness/less shedding (Sam's Mark), with opinions split and recent trends favoring Sam's for softness over the often-harsher Kirkland, say Reddit and Facebook users.

Who makes Sam's Club brand toilet paper?

Sam's Club toilet paper is made under their store brand, Member's Mark, but the actual manufacturer is a private label company, often rumored to be Georgia-Pacific (makers of Bounty/Quilted Northern), though Sam's Club doesn't officially name them, focusing instead on quality & value for the Member's Mark brand. 

Is Sam's Club lower quality than Costco?

General Trend: Sam's Club tends to have slightly lower prices overall, especially on packaged foods and everyday basics. Costco often offers higher quality, especially on fresh foods and their Kirkland Signature products.

How does Costco toilet paper compare to others?

One shopper claims the toilet tissue has "gone from the best to the worst" and is now the "strength of cotton candy." Others echo this, saying the tissue is "flimsy, shreds completely," and "the sheets are too hard to separate." Another Costco customer claims that the paper isn't even a good value, as they now have to ...

Why not buy Kirkland toilet paper?

Costco's Kirkland toilet paper has faced significant customer complaints recently, with users reporting a major decline in quality: it's become thin, dusty, messy, difficult to tear cleanly, and leaves lint, with some users experiencing plumbing issues or skin irritation. Many shoppers feel the rolls are smaller (shrinkflation), the paper is less soft, and they're switching to alternatives like Charmin due to the increased dust and poor performance, despite higher prices.
 

Costco vs Sam’s Club: Toilet Paper Showdown!

Is Costco a good place to buy toilet paper?

Yes, Costco's Kirkland toilet paper is generally considered a good deal due to its low price per sheet compared to name brands, offering significant savings on bulk purchases, but its perceived quality has declined for some shoppers who find it thinner and lintier, meaning you might use more sheets per use, potentially negating some value for those prioritizing softness and durability. 

What is Sam's Club offering that Costco won't match?

Sam's Club offers more flexible payments (all major credit cards), curbside pickup, better app integration (Scan & Go, cake ordering), a wider variety of name-brand snack options (like 2-liter sodas), and personalized bakery cakes, while Costco focuses more on Kirkland organic products, has stricter payment rules (Visa only in-store), and lacks curbside/Scan & Go. 

What competitive advantage does Costco have over Sam's Club?

At first glance, Costco and Sam's Club appear to be mirror images. Both operate cavernous warehouses, both require memberships, and both offer low prices on bulk goods. Yet Costco generates stronger loyalty, higher renewal rates, and greater profit per member.

Which toilet paper is better, Charmin or Kirkland?

No, Kirkland toilet paper isn't quite as good as Charmin for softness and strength, but it offers better value; Charmin Ultra Soft/Strong is generally considered softer, thicker, and less prone to finger-poking, while Kirkland is a more budget-friendly alternative that can be thinner, sometimes leaves lint, but lasts longer per roll and is better for septic systems due to faster breakdown. 

What toilet paper do plumbers not recommend?

Ultra-Soft or Plush Toilet Paper

Ultra-soft varieties are often thick and don't dissolve easily. They can clog pipes and contribute to buildup over time, especially in homes with smaller or older pipes.

Does Sam's Club offer different toilet paper brands?

When you shop at Sam's Club, you can buy premium bath tissue brands like Charmin, Angel Soft, Cottonelle, Scott and Quilted Northern in bulk, which means you'll make fewer trips to the store and get the best prices on mega rolls of these ultra strong, ultra soft toilet paper/bath tissue brands.

Where is Costco's Kirkland toilet paper made?

Kirkland Signature toilet paper is made by major paper manufacturers like Clearwater Paper and Georgia-Pacific, with production occurring in various North American facilities, primarily the United States (e.g., Washington, Idaho, Arkansas) and Canada, depending on the specific product and Costco location, often using sustainably sourced North American pulp. 

Who manufactures Sam's Club toilet paper?

Sam's Club toilet paper, sold under the Member's Mark brand, is a private label, meaning it's made by various third-party manufacturers contracted by Walmart/Sam's Club, often the same companies that produce big-name brands, though the exact factory varies, with possibilities including Georgia-Pacific or other major paper producers, focusing on value rather than a single supplier. 

Why do people prefer Costco over Sam's Club?

Costco often feels more popular due to its perception as a premium retailer with higher-quality private-label (Kirkland Signature) products, better employee treatment, and a "treasure hunt" shopping experience, attracting loyal customers who value curated selection and strong brand identity, while Sam's Club appeals more to budget-focused shoppers with generally lower prices on more name-brand items and convenient tech like Scan & Go, making popularity a matter of consumer priorities rather than overall sales. 

What is the .97 rule at Costco?

Ends in .

There are many indications for sale prices at Costco, and ending in . 97 is one of them. It means corporate or merchandise buyers mark the price down. The sign won't say what the original price was, but you can be sure you're getting a deal.

Why are people boycotting Sam's and Walmart?

The People's Union USA is calling for a boycott of Walmart, Sam's Club, and their associated brands from May 20-26. The group cites reasons including alleged underpaid workers, corporate subsidies, and the displacement of small businesses.

Who is bigger, Sam's or Costco?

Yes, Costco is generally considered bigger than Sam's Club, with larger average store sizes (around 146,000 sq ft vs. 136,000 sq ft) and a greater global presence, though Sam's Club has many locations, especially dominating in the South and Midwest US, notes Business Insider, Eat This Not That and Yahoo. Costco also has significantly higher overall sales and market share, notes Yahoo and Quora.

Which is better, Charmin or Kirkland toilet paper?

No, Kirkland toilet paper isn't quite as good as Charmin for softness and strength, but it offers better value; Charmin Ultra Soft/Strong is generally considered softer, thicker, and less prone to finger-poking, while Kirkland is a more budget-friendly alternative that can be thinner, sometimes leaves lint, but lasts longer per roll and is better for septic systems due to faster breakdown. 

What is the softest toilet paper at Costco?

Charmin Ultra Soft Bath Tissue, 2-Ply, 213 Sheets, 30 Rolls

Wider sheets; New & improved; Our softest, & most absorbent with smooth tear; Septic safe; 2-Ply, 4.5" x 4.2" Sheet Size; 213 Sheets per Roll; 30 Rolls; 835 Total sq. ft.

Is toilet paper cheaper at Costco than Walmart?

Generally, Costco is cheaper per roll or square for its Kirkland brand due to bulk savings, but Walmart's Great Value can sometimes beat Costco's base price, especially when factoring in sales, though you'd have to do the "toilet paper math" (per square foot/sheet) to be sure, as Costco often gives you more sheets for your money despite a slightly higher upfront cost for the large pack.