Who makes the best apple pie in America?

There's no single "best," but top contenders for US apple pie include The Elegant Farmer (WI) for its unique paper-bag baked crust, Julian Pie Company (CA) for classic, crisp apples and crumble, Four and Twenty Blackbirds (NY) for salted caramel apple, and grocery store winners like Sprouts (fresh) and Kirkland Signature/Costco (frozen), praised for flavor balance and flaky crusts. The "best" often depends on preference for flaky crust, sweet/tart filling, or special toppings like caramel or streusel.

Who has the best apple pie in America?

1. Albertsons The Albertsons bakery pulls off a stunning victory by conjuring an apple pie that hits all the right notes in a pitch-perfect symphony of flavor and consistency. Who knew this corner of the store held so much delicious dessert potential?

What is the #1 pie in the US?

The #1 pie in America, consistently topping sales and preference lists, is Apple Pie, a classic dessert that accounts for nearly 30% of all pie sales, followed by Pumpkin and Pecan pies as top contenders, according to recent data. While regional favorites exist, apple pie remains the dominant choice, though some surveys also highlight pizza as a popular savory "pie," especially among men, and specific shops like Stockholm Pie in WI & MN are recognized as top pie destinations.
 

Which supermarket makes the best apple pie?

The best store-bought apple pie often depends on preference (fresh vs. frozen, flaky vs. crumbly), but Marie Callender's Dutch Apple wins for homemade feel (especially with streusel), while Costco's Kirkland Signature and Sprouts' Bakery pies are top contenders for ready-to-eat options with great filling and flaky crusts. For classic frozen, Sara Lee offers a decent flaky crust, though some find it basic. 

Is Sara Lee or Marie Callender's better?

Neither Sara Lee nor Marie Callender's is universally "better"; it depends on the pie flavor and your preference for crust vs. filling, with Marie Callender's often praised for authentic, chunky fruit fillings (like apple) and Sara Lee sometimes favored for its sweeter, firmer pies (like pumpkin) or superior crusts (like lemon meringue), though reviewers are divided, with some finding Sara Lee's apple mushy and others loving its cookies & creme cheesecake texture. 

Which Types of Apples Are Best for Baking Pies, and Why? | America's Test Kitchen

Which frozen apple pie is best?

For the best frozen apple pie, food experts widely recommend Marie Callender's Dutch Apple Pie, praised for its flaky crust, chunky apple filling with good cinnamon spice, and delicious streusel topping, making it taste homemade, though Kirkland Signature (Costco) also scores high for its balanced flavor and crust, while Sara Lee offers a good classic option if you prefer tart apples, say sources 1, 2, 4, 5, 7.

What is the number one selling pie?

The best-selling pie in the U.S. is Apple Pie, consistently topping charts, followed by classic favorites like Pumpkin, Pecan, and Cherry, according to recent 2024/2025 data from Instacart. While sweet pies dominate, savory options like chicken pot pie are also popular, especially regionally, with regional variations showing strong preferences for Key Lime in the West, Sweet Potato in the South, and unique flavors like Marionberry in the Pacific Northwest.
 

What grocery store makes the best apple pie?

The "best" grocery store apple pie is subjective, but recent taste tests frequently crown Costco's Kirkland Signature Apple Pie for its large size, flavorful filling, and sugary crust, while Albertsons (especially with Jessie Lord pies) and Sprouts also receive high praise for fresh, balanced, and flaky options, with Marie Callender's being a top frozen choice. 

What is the number one pie shop in America?

World Famous Pie!

Stockholm Pie is legendary for its amazing pie. Named the #1 Pie Shop in America by USAToday in 2024 and 2025 and recognized as one of the 11 Iconic Pie Shops in America by Food and Wine Magazine!

What is Barack Obama's favorite pie?

President Barack Obama's Favorite Apple Pie

• 3 lb apples, skinned, cored, and cut into 1/2" wedges (Honeycrisp, Gala, Granny...
• 1 lemon, zested and juiced.
• 1 egg.
• 3 cup all-purpose flour.
• 1/2 cup artisanal honey, preferably local.
• 1/3 cup cornstarch.
• 1 tsp pure vanilla extract.
• 1/4 tsp ground cinnamon.

What is Dolly Parton's favorite pie?

Serve slices with a "Dolly-up" of whipped cream. There's nobody better at throwing an old-fashioned country Christmas than Dolly Parton. And her Christmases always include a walnut pie.

Which pie is the unhealthiest?

There's no single "most unhealthy" pie, as it depends on ingredients, but Pecan Pie and rich, candy-loaded pies like Snickers Pie often top lists due to extreme sugar and fat, while creamy chocolate or coconut pies also rank high in calories and unhealthy fats, with commercial versions using partially hydrogenated oils. Classic fruit pies like apple or pumpkin are often seen as better, but still contain significant sugar and calories in their crusts.
 

Which fast food place has the best apple pie?

The best fast-food apple pie is often debated, but Popeyes (deep-fried, cinnamon-sugar crust), KFC (bite-sized "Poppers" with flaky crust and real apple chunks), and McDonald's (classic baked with real fruit) are top contenders, with some fans also loving Whataburger and Arby's turnovers for their unique styles. Your personal favorite depends on whether you prefer a crispy, fried crust or a flaky, baked one, and the amount of cinnamon and real fruit chunks.
 

What is the secret to the best apple pie?

A good apple pie features a flaky, buttery crust and a filling with tender-yet-distinct chunks of tart and sweet apples, bound in a light glaze, allowing the fresh fruit flavor to shine without being overly spiced, gloppy, or mushy, requiring techniques like using a mix of firm apples, keeping ingredients cold, and potentially par-cooking the apples.
 

What are the top 10 pies in the United States?

The top 10 most popular pies in America consistently feature classics like Apple, Pumpkin, Pecan, and Cherry, followed by creamy options such as Lemon Meringue, Chocolate, Key Lime, Blueberry, Banana Cream, and Peach, with these rankings often based on recent sales data from services like Instacart Better Homes & Gardens and Food & Wine, showing Apple Pie and Pumpkin Pie as perennial favorites. 

Who has the best frozen pie?

For the best frozen pies, Marie Callender's consistently wins top spots in taste tests for its flaky crusts and flavorful fillings, especially the Dutch Apple Pie, while brands like Edwards and Sara Lee are often praised for cream/chocolate pies, though Marie Callender's also offers variety in those categories, making it a go-to for quality and comfort. 

What are the top five pies?

The top 5 pies consistently include classics like Apple, Pumpkin, and Pecan, often followed by fruit pies like Cherry, Blueberry, and Key Lime, with rich Chocolate or creamy options like Banana Cream and Lemon Meringue also highly ranked, reflecting a mix of traditional flavors and creamy favorites in American preferences. 

What restaurant chain is famous for pies?

Bakers Square Restaurant & Bakery (also known as Bakers Square) is a casual dining restaurant chain in the United States. Known for its pies, Bakers Square also offers full breakfast, lunch and dinner menus. The chain is owned by BBQ Holdings.

Which supermarket sells the best apple pie?

Top 10 Apple Pies

• M&S. Apple & Blackberry Puff Pastry Pie. ...
• Tesco. Apple Lattice Pie. ...
• Waitrose Ltd. Waitrose Frozen Normandy Apple Tart. ...
• Tesco. Apple Tart. ...
• Sainsbury's. Apple & Blackberry Pie Dessert. ...
• Picard. Apple Tart A La Normande. ...
• Glade. Large Automatic Spray Refill Warm Apple Pie. ...
• Glade. Sense & Spray Holder Warm Apple Pie. 18ml.

Which apple pie is better, Marie Callender or Sara Lee?

The consensus was that Marie Callender's pie tasted the most authentic and the best overall. That said, Mrs. Smith's and Sara Lee both had something to offer. If you like your pies tart, go with Sara Lee.

Who has the best apple pie, Sam's or Costco?

Costco's apple pie is often praised for a more balanced, homemade taste with better crust quality and less artificial sweetness, making it a favorite for overall balance, while Sam's Club's Member's Mark pie is known for its indulgent, syrupy, and sweeter profile that appeals to those wanting dessert-first flavors, often featuring a thicker, sweeter crust. The choice depends on preference: Costco for a more nuanced, quality bake, Sam's Club for pure, sugary indulgence. 

What state eats the most pie?

Which states order the most pie?

• Kansas: 361% more pie orders.
• Nevada: 264% more pie orders.
• New Mexico: 261% more pie orders.
• Arizona: 246% more pie orders.
• Indiana: 173% more pie orders.
• Missouri: 145% more pie orders.
• West Virginia: 135% more pie orders.
• Michigan: 126% more pie orders.

What pie is eaten 50 million times a year?

The pie eaten around 50 million times a year, primarily during Thanksgiving, is the pumpkin pie, with estimates suggesting over 50 million are consumed in the U.S. during that holiday season alone, surpassing even turkey consumption. While apple pie is a year-round favorite, pumpkin pie dominates the fall and holiday dessert landscape.
 

Who won the best pie?

The full list of the 2025 major winners are:

• Winner of the Plain Pie: Paradise Bakehouse, Bundaberg QLD – Mince.
• Runner up Plain Pie: The Pie Father, Rosebery NSW – Mince.
• Winner of the Plain Sausage Roll: Banana Boogie, Belair SA – Beef.
• Winner of the Gourmet Pie: Mt Barket County Bakehouse, WA – Beef Bourguignon.